Here are the rules for starting a discussion in the replay forum:
1. The name of the thread should start with [RACE v RACE].
2. Include the name of the respective players in the title.
3. If needed, include name of the tournament/competiton in the titile.
4. Include a full description of the game in the first few lines of your post.
5. Remember to upload the replay externally, and to provide a link.
6. If you are planning on discussing a replay hosted on another website (GosuGamers, sc2replays, etc.), provide a link to that replay.
Example Replay Thread:
Topic Title: [PvZ]LiquidHuK vs Eg.Idra
Team 1: LiquidHuk - Protoss
Team 2: Eg.Idra - Zerg
Exhibiton Match
Xel'naga Caverns
Winner:
- Spoiler:
LiquidHuK
[Continue discussion]
NOTE: Preferably upload all replays to Media Fire. They have been generally been reliable in the past.